Halal pizza in Greater Indianapolis
10 places, with what the owner or the community says about the meat.
What the evidence says
Own claim, backed by the community: The place says halal on its own site or menu, and a community source agrees.1
Community evidence only: A community source lists it as halal. The place itself makes no halal claim.3
Part of the menu: Only some menu items are halal.6
Strongest evidence first
All 10 places
Pakistani-influenced pizza, wings & burgersOpen now
Magoo’s California PizzaInternational MarketplaceOwn claim, backed by the community: The place says halal on its own site or menu, and a community source agrees. Owner says halal. Community listing. Checked July 30, 2026.
AmericanOpen now
Magoo's California PizzaAvonCommunity evidence only: A community source lists it as halal. The place itself makes no halal claim. Listed as halal. Community listing. Checked September 6, 2026.
ItalianOpen now
Pizza Palace CaliforniaIndianapolisCommunity evidence only: A community source lists it as halal. The place itself makes no halal claim. Menu says halal. Checked September 5, 2026.
Italian
Pizza PizzaIndianapolisCommunity evidence only: A community source lists it as halal. The place itself makes no halal claim. Muslim owners confirm. Checked September 3, 2026.
ItalianOpen now
Maestro PizzaFishers“Halal and fresh pizza from the oven to you everything fresh”Part of the menu: Only some menu items are halal. Owner says halal. Menu says halal. Checked September 5, 2026.
ItalianOpen now
Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza & PastaMcCordsvillePart of the menu: Only some menu items are halal. Listed as halal. Checked September 6, 2026.
ItalianOpen now
Papa Ray's Pizza & WingsIndianapolisPart of the menu: Only some menu items are halal. Listed as halal. Checked September 3, 2026.
IndianOpen now
Pizza TwistGreenwoodPart of the menu: Only some menu items are halal. Listed as halal. Checked September 6, 2026.
IndianOpen now
Pizza TwistFishersPart of the menu: Only some menu items are halal. Listed as halal. Checked September 5, 2026.
IndianOpen now
Pizza TwistPlainfieldPart of the menu: Only some menu items are halal. Listed as halal. Checked September 5, 2026.
More to eat
Other halal food in Greater Indianapolis
Indian food19 placesMediterranean food11 placesCoffee shops9 placesFried chicken9 placesMiddle Eastern food9 placesBurgers5 placesShawarma and kebab4 placesMarkets3 places
All halal food