Bakery & DessertsBakery
Problem Baker
870 Castleton Avenue, Staten Island, NY
Monday10 AM to 9 PMTuesday10 AM to 9 PMWednesday10 AM to 9 PMThursday10 AM to 9 PMFriday10 AM to 9 PMSaturday10 AM to 9 PMSunday10 AM to 9 PMChecked October 25, 2026.
A community source lists it as halal. The place itself makes no halal claim. Checked August 11, 2026.
The evidence
Is Problem Baker halal?
Problem Baker makes no halal claim of its own. A community source lists it as halal.
The communityA community listing.
Pray in Staten Island
Masjids in the same area
Also in Staten Island
More halal food
PakistaniOpen now
Heat FlamesStaten Island“Heat Flames USA is a standout destination for bold Pakistani flavors and halal comfort food.”Own claim, backed by the community: The place says halal on its own site or menu, and a community source agrees. Owner says halal. Listed as halal. Checked August 11, 2026.
American
YalaStaten Island“Bold halal American comfort food, sunrise to late night.”Own claim, backed by the community: The place says halal on its own site or menu, and a community source agrees. Owner says halal. Halal sign on site. Checked August 11, 2026.
AmericanOpen now
YalaStaten Island“Bold halal American comfort food, sunrise to late night.”Own claim, backed by the community: The place says halal on its own site or menu, and a community source agrees. Owner says halal. Halal sign on site. Checked August 11, 2026.
PalestinianOpen now
Charcoal GardeniaStaten IslandOwn claim, backed by the community: The place says halal on its own site or menu, and a community source agrees. Owner says halal. Menu says halal. Checked August 11, 2026.
Groceries, halal meat & LebaneseOpen now
Lebanese EateryStaten IslandOwn claim, backed by the community: The place says halal on its own site or menu, and a community source agrees. Owner says halal. Halal sign on site. Checked August 11, 2026.
IndianOpen now
Al-HumzaStaten IslandCommunity evidence only: A community source lists it as halal. The place itself makes no halal claim. Listed as halal. Checked August 11, 2026.