Halal burgers in Indianapolis, IN
3 places, with what the owner or the community says about the meat.
What the evidence says
Own claim, backed by the community: The place says halal on its own site or menu, and a community source agrees.2
Community evidence only: A community source lists it as halal. The place itself makes no halal claim.1
Strongest evidence first
All 3 places
Pakistani-influenced pizza, wings & burgersOpen now
Magoo’s California PizzaInternational MarketplaceOwn claim, backed by the community: The place says halal on its own site or menu, and a community source agrees. Owner says halal. Community listing. Checked July 30, 2026.
New York halal platters, gyros & burgersOpen now
NYC Halal Eats, ShadelandCastletonOwn claim, backed by the community: The place says halal on its own site or menu, and a community source agrees. Owner says halal. Certifier lists it. Checked July 30, 2026.
American
Holy Smash BurgersIndianapolisCommunity evidence only: A community source lists it as halal. The place itself makes no halal claim. Muslim owners confirm. Checked September 14, 2026.