Speak about Islam only with knowledge
“We all have to limit ourselves to speak only about what we are sure about.”
Disagreement is a natural test, but Muslims must distinguish legitimate scholarly differences from error and avoid speaking about Islam without knowledge.
The khutbah in 5 steps
- The Quran acknowledges disagreement among humanity, believers, prophets, and companions.
- Open-ended matters test sincerity, effort, and the pursuit of truth.
- Scholars differ because evidence may be unavailable, authenticity disputed, or interpretation varied.
- Unqualified people must not issue religious rulings; they should ask knowledgeable scholars.
- Knowledge helps Muslims distinguish tolerable differences from beliefs and errors that cannot be accepted.
In the khateeb's words
“In fact, even among the prophets, you're going to have different opinions.”
“But the Prophet, he made this reward conditional on someone being qualified to make that ruling.”
“Because the only cure for ignorance is to ask a question.”
“We all have to limit ourselves to speak only about what we are sure about, what we have knowledge about.”
For the dinner table
Today's khutbah reminded us that disagreements can happen even among sincere, knowledgeable people. The khateeb shared examples of prophets and companions reaching different judgments while still being treated with respect. He explained that scholars may differ because they have different information, assess a report's authenticity differently, or understand the same words differently. At the same time, he warned us that giving religious advice without knowledge can cause real harm, and that the reward for a mistaken judgment depends on being qualified. We can practice humility by saying “I don't know,” asking people of knowledge, and seeking their guidance about which differences allow room for disagreement.
- What could you say to show respect when someone understands something differently from you?
- When has learning something new helped you change your mind?
- What could help you say “I don't know” when someone asks you a difficult religious question?
More on Seeking knowledge
IMAN Center · Kirkland, WA · Sep 19, 2026Knowledge matters only when it changes us“Sometimes the problem is knowledge without action.”
Daar-Ul-Islam · Ballwin, MO · Oct 3, 2026The first revelation calls us to learn and serve“Before any type of great transformation occurs outwardly, there must be deep reflection inwardly.”
CCIL-KBW · Laval, QC · Sep 26, 2026Protect your heart from information overload“Faire confiance à Allah ne signifie pas rester sans rien faire.”